← AcademiaOne PhD Hub · 返回首页
AcademiaOneEDUCATION
PhD Research Proposal Guide · HK · Business 香港商科研究计划书指南
AcademiaOneEDUCATION
Your PhD application, from idea to offer你的博士申请,从构想到录取
DOCTORAL APPLICATIONS · HONG KONG · BUSINESS & MANAGEMENT   香港商科博士申请

PhD Research
Proposal Guide · Business

香港商科博士研究计划书写作指南

A section-by-section model of a business-school PhD research proposal for Hong Kong. Each part shows the structure, a fully worked example from finance and accounting, and the difference between a weak and a stronger version, with the current requirements of HK business schools taken from their official pages.

逐部分拆解一份香港商学院博士研究计划书。每一部分都包含结构说明、一个完整的金融与会计范例,以及“较弱”与“更好”写法的对比,并附香港各商学院官网上的最新要求。

Start here 开始之前

What Hong Kong universities ask for香港各校要求

Hong Kong universities ask for a research proposal or a research plan in almost every field, but the form differs: HKU faculties set their own format, PolyU uses Form GSB/1A, HKUST takes a research plan typed into the online form, and CityU calls the document a research plan in several schools. The Hong Kong PhD Fellowship Scheme (HKPFS) and the main round at HKU and CUHK all close on 1 December 2026, the earliest deadline of the year, so plan backwards from that date.

香港各校几乎所有学科都要求提交研究计划书(有的称为“研究计划”),但形式各不相同:港大各学院自定格式,理大使用 GSB/1A 表格,港科大要求在网申表格中直接填写研究计划,城大多个学院称之为“研究计划”。香港博士研究生奖学金计划(HKPFS)与港大、港中文的主轮申请都在 2026 年 12 月 1 日截止,是一年中最早的截止日期,请以此倒推时间表。

Hong Kong business schools all expect a test score and a written research plan, in different forms. HKU Business School asks for a proposal of 6-8 pages and a GMAT or GRE score taken within five years; CUHK for a personal statement plus a research proposal or plan; HKUST for a proposal plus a vision statement of up to 2,000 characters; PolyU for Form GSB/1A; and CityU Management for a research plan, with GMAT or GRE strongly encouraged.

香港商学院都看重考试成绩和书面研究计划,只是形式不同。港大商学院要求 6-8 页计划书和五年内的 GMAT 或 GRE 成绩;港中文要求个人陈述加研究计划;港科大要求计划书加不超过 2,000 字符的愿景陈述;理大使用 GSB/1A 表格;城大管理学要求研究计划,并强烈建议提交 GMAT 或 GRE。

Business: what each programme asks for商科:各项目要求

UNIVERSITY 大学WHAT THE PROGRAMME ASKS FOR 项目要求UNIVERSITY-WIDE RULE 全校规定OFFICIAL PAGE 官方页面
HKU
香港大学
QS 2027: 11
Proposal 6-8 pages
GMAT/GRE required (within 5 years)
References: 2
Proposal or statement of research interest in faculty format
gradsch.hku.hk
phd.hkubs.hku.hk
CUHK
香港中文大学
QS 2027: 18
Personal statement + research proposal/plan
GMAT/GRE score reports (codes listed)
References: 3
Not stated centrallygrad.bschool.cuhk.edu.hk
HKUST
香港科技大学
QS 2027: 33
Research proposal + vision (≤2,000 characters)
GMAT/GRE required
References: 2+
Research topic and plan in form; extra proposal for Humanities and Social Science
fytgs.hkust.edu.hk
bmphd.hkust.edu.hk
PolyU
香港理工大学
QS 2027: 50
Form GSB/1A
GMAT/GRE required (Management: GMAT Focus 605 / GMAT 650)
References: 2
Compulsory on Form GSB1a
polyu.edu.hk
polyu.edu.hk
CityU
香港城市大学
QS 2027: 52
Research plan
GMAT/GRE strongly encouraged
References: 2
Required for Liberal Arts & Social Sciences, Creative Media, Energy & Environment, Law
cityu.edu.hk
cb.cityu.edu.hk

Requirements are quoted from the official page linked in each row, in English as published. The third column is the university-wide proposal rule from the graduate school page. 表中要求按各行所附官方页面的英文原文摘录;第三栏为研究生院页面上的全校计划书规定。

Golden rule 核心原则

The programme page always beats this guide. Use this guide to decide what to write; use the programme page to decide how long it is and what form it takes.

项目官网的要求永远优先于本指南。用本指南决定“写什么”,用项目页面决定“写多长、用什么格式”。

HKPFS comes first HKPFS 最先截止

The HKPFS has two steps. Get an HKPFS reference number on the Research Grants Council (RGC) system by 12:00 noon HKT on 1 December 2026, then apply to up to two programmes at one or two universities, quoting it, by 11:59 pm the same day. Universities pre-screen and nominate candidates, and HKPFS applicants are considered for each university’s own awards. Later rounds exist: CUHK clearing closes on 31 March 2027 and HKU Medicine on 30 April.

HKPFS 分两步:先在研究资助局(RGC)系统取得 HKPFS 编号,截止时间为 2026 年 12 月 1 日香港时间中午 12 点;再在当天晚上 11:59 前,凭该编号向一至两所大学的最多两个项目提交申请。各校先行筛选并提名候选人,HKPFS 申请人也会自动参与各校自设奖学金的评选。之后还有补录轮:港中文补录轮于 2027 年 3 月 31 日截止,港大医学院为 4 月 30 日。

Referees 推荐人

HKU, PolyU and CityU ask for two academic referees, HKUST for at least two (the form takes up to five), and CUHK for three for research doctorates. At PolyU your proposed supervisor cannot be one of your referees.

港大、理大和城大要求两位学术推荐人,港科大至少两位(表格最多可填五位),港中文研究型博士要求三位。理大规定拟定导师不能担任推荐人。

Plan your test early 尽早安排考试

A GMAT or GRE score is required at HKU (taken within five years), HKUST and PolyU (Management: GMAT Focus 605 or GMAT 650), sent as a score report at CUHK, and strongly encouraged at CityU. Book the test so the score arrives before 1 December 2026.

港大(五年内成绩)、港科大和理大(管理学:GMAT Focus 605 或 GMAT 650)要求 GMAT 或 GRE 成绩,港中文要求寄送成绩单,城大强烈建议提交。请尽早预约考试,让成绩在 2026 年 12 月 1 日前送到。

Table built from 5 official programme pages (each checked on the programme page itself; data checked 2026-11-18). Rules change each cycle; the programme page always wins. 表格依据 5 个官方项目页面整理(均在项目页面本身核对;数据核对日期 2026-11-18)。规则每年可能调整,以项目页面为准。

Start here 开始之前

Three kinds of business proposal三种商科计划书

Business schools use three levels of document, and some name all three and assign them by discipline. Find out which level your school wants, then write that one well.

商学院的申请文件分三个层级,有的学校明确列出这三种并按学科分配。先弄清学校要哪一层级,再把它写好。

LEVEL 层级WHAT IT IS 是什么WHERE YOU MEET IT 常见于
1 · Statement of research interests
研究兴趣陈述
One to two pages on the questions that interest you, the methods you can use, and the faculty whose work fits. No full design.
一到两页,写你感兴趣的问题、你能使用的方法,以及研究方向契合的老师。不需要完整设计。
In Hong Kong this role is played by the short statements that go with the proposal: the HKUST vision statement (up to 2,000 characters) and the CUHK personal statement.
在香港,这一层级由随计划书提交的简短陈述承担:港科大的愿景陈述(不超过 2,000 字符)和港中文的个人陈述。
2 · Indicative proposal
初步研究计划
Up to about 1,500 words: one question, the hypotheses, the data you would use and why it matters. A starting point for talking to a supervisor.
约 1,500 词以内:一个问题、研究假设、拟用数据及其意义。是与导师讨论的起点。
CityU Management (research plan), PolyU (Form GSB/1A), CUHK (research proposal or plan), HKUST (research proposal with the vision statement).
城大管理学(研究计划)、理大(GSB/1A 表格)、港中文(研究计划)、港科大(研究计划加愿景陈述)。
3 · Developed proposal
完整研究计划
3,000 words or more: theory, hypotheses, data and identification, expected results, contribution and timeline.
3,000 词以上:理论、假设、数据与识别策略、预期结果、贡献与时间安排。
HKU Business School (6-8 pages).
港大商学院(6-8 页)。

Why some top schools ask for less为什么部分顶尖学校要求更少

Schools that ask for a plan or a form rather than a long proposal, such as CityU Management (a research plan) and PolyU (Form GSB/1A), expect your topic to develop once you start. They read your statement for research potential, quantitative preparation and fit, not for a finished design. A clear hypothesis and a credible data source still count in your favour.

要求研究计划或表格、而不是长篇计划书的学校(如城大管理学的研究计划、理大的 GSB/1A 表格),都预期你的课题在入学后会继续发展。他们看的是你的研究潜力、量化基础与匹配度,而不是完整的设计。不过,清晰的假设和可信的数据来源仍然会给你加分。

Start here 开始之前

How long, and how the words are shared篇幅与字数分配

Write one full master version of about 3,000 words, then cut it to size. Business panels spend most of their time on the hypotheses and the data and identification sections, so those get the most words. In Hong Kong the limit is often set in pages or by a form (HKU Arts 4-5 pages double-spaced, HKUST Social Science 10-12 pages, HKU Education up to 20 pages), so check the spacing and whether references count before you cut.

先写一份约 3,000 词的完整母版,再按要求裁剪。商科评审把大部分时间花在假设和数据与识别策略上,所以这两部分字数最多。在香港,篇幅上限常以页数或表格来规定(港大文学院 4-5 页双倍行距,港科大社会科学部 10-12 页,港大教育学院不超过 20 页);裁剪之前请确认行距要求以及参考文献是否计入。

2004008001000350250
0 Title & abstract1 Motivation & question2 Literature & hypotheses3 Data & identification4 Contribution & fit5 Timeline & feasibility

If you are applying in another business field其他商科方向

FIELD 方向WHAT PANELS LOOK FOR 评审关注
Finance · Accounting
金融 · 会计
Archival data (CSMAR, Wind, Compustat, CRSP), a named identification strategy and clean hypotheses.
档案数据(CSMAR、Wind、Compustat、CRSP)、明确的识别策略和清晰的假设。
Management · Organisational behaviour
管理 · 组织行为
A theory you extend, measured constructs, and a survey, field or lab design with access to organisations.
要延伸的理论、可测量的构念,以及能接触到企业的问卷、实地或实验设计。
Marketing
市场营销
Behavioural: a series of experiments with a mechanism. Quantitative: a demand or choice model with real transaction data.
行为方向:一组揭示机制的实验。量化方向:基于真实交易数据的需求或选择模型。
Operations · Information systems
运营 · 信息系统
A clearly defined model or platform setting, the data or simulation, and the managerial decision it informs.
清晰界定的模型或平台情境、数据或仿真,以及它服务的管理决策。

The five questions every business panel asks商科评审必问的五个问题

#PANEL QUESTION 评审问题WHERE YOU ANSWER IT 在哪里回答
1Is this an important question for theory and practice? 这个问题对理论和实践都重要吗?Motivation · Abstract 研究动机 · 摘要
2Are the hypotheses derived from theory, not guessed? 假设是由理论推导出来的,还是凭空猜测?Literature & hypotheses 文献与假设
3Can the data and design separate cause from correlation? 数据和设计能区分因果与相关吗?Data & identification 数据与识别
4Does this person have the quantitative training to do it? 申请人有完成它所需的量化训练吗?Data & identification · CV · test score 数据与识别 · 简历 · 考试成绩
5Why this school and these faculty? 为什么是这所学校、这些老师?Contribution & fit 贡献与匹配度
Before you write 动笔之前

The golden thread逻辑主线

A business proposal works when each part follows from the one before: a puzzle leads to a question, theory turns the question into hypotheses, and the data and identification test them. If you cannot write these four sentences, narrow the topic before drafting anything else.

好的商科计划书环环相扣:现实中的困惑引出研究问题,理论把问题变成假设,数据与识别策略检验假设。如果写不出这四句话,先把课题缩小再动笔。

PUZZLE研究困惑

Foreign investors are said to push firms towards better ESG disclosure, but it is hard to tell whether they cause better disclosure or simply choose firms that already disclose well.

QUESTION研究问题

Does access by foreign investors improve the quality of firms’ ESG disclosure?

IDENTIFICATION识别策略

Use the staggered inclusion of Chinese A-share firms in Stock Connect as a shock to foreign access, in a difference-in-differences design.

CONTRIBUTION研究贡献

Causal evidence on investor-driven disclosure in an emerging market, and guidance for regulators designing market-opening policy.

The worked example used in this guide本指南使用的范例

Example applicant 范例申请人

Background 背景
BCom Accounting (Mainland China); MSc Finance (UK), with a dissertation on ESG ratings and the cost of capital; research assistant on a corporate-governance project using CSMAR data.

Applying to 申请
PhD in Accounting or Finance at business schools in Hong Kong; GMAT or GRE taken.

Working title 暂定题目
Opening the Door: Foreign Investor Access and ESG Disclosure Quality in Chinese Listed Firms

How to use the example 如何使用范例

The same finance and accounting proposal appears in every section so you can watch one project move from puzzle to timeline. Don’t copy the topic. Study the moves, the numbered notes beside each extract, then make the same moves with your own field, data and supervisor. Citations shown as (Authors, Year) are placeholders; in your own proposal every claim needs a real source you have read. Facts about your setting, such as policy dates, must be checked against official sources. The examples are in English only, because your application will be written in English.

同一份金融与会计计划书贯穿每个部分,方便你看到一个项目如何从研究困惑一路走到时间安排。不要照搬课题,要学习写法:先看每段旁边的编号解析,再用你自己的方向、数据和导师做同样的事。(Authors, Year) 为占位符,你自己的计划书里每个论断都必须有你读过的真实文献;政策日期等情境事实也必须用官方资料核实。范例仅用英文,因为你的申请材料也用英文写。

Section 0 第 0 部分
0

Title & Abstract题目与摘要

Typical length 典型篇幅 title 10-18 words · abstract 150-250 words

Business titles name the cause, the outcome and the setting. Many add “Evidence from …” to signal the data or the natural experiment. The abstract states the question, the identification and the contribution in plain language.

商科题目要写出原因、结果与情境,常见做法是加上“Evidence from …”来点明数据或自然实验。摘要用平实的语言说清研究问题、识别策略与贡献。

Anatomy of a title题目结构

Opening the Door: Hook (optional) 开头(可选)
Foreign Investor Access and ESG Disclosure Quality Cause + outcome 原因 + 结果
in Chinese Listed Firms Setting 情境

Weak vs stronger titles较弱与更好的题目

✕ Weak 较弱“A Study of ESG in China”

No cause, no outcome, no design. The panel cannot tell what you will test.

没有原因、结果和设计,评审看不出你要检验什么。

✓ Stronger 更好“Foreign Investor Access and ESG Disclosure Quality: Evidence from Stock Connect”

Names the cause, the outcome and the natural experiment in one line.

一行之内写出原因、结果与自然实验。

✕ Weak 较弱“How Foreign Investors Make Chinese Firms Better”

Assumes the answer and sounds like a headline.

预设了答案,读起来像新闻标题。

✓ Stronger 更好“Do Foreign Investors Improve Corporate Disclosure? Evidence from China”

Neutral, testable and clear about the setting.

中立、可检验,情境清楚。

Management 管理 Remote Work and Team Innovation: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Chinese Technology Firms
Marketing 营销 Scarcity Messages and Impulse Purchases on Live-Streaming Platforms: Five Experiments
Operations 运营 Dynamic Pricing for Same-Day Delivery under Demand Uncertainty
Section 0 continued 第 0 部分(续)

The abstract摘要

Blueprint结构

1Move 1 · Puzzle

The real-world fact that raises the question.

引出问题的现实事实。

2Move 2 · Gap

Why existing evidence cannot answer it.

为什么现有证据无法回答。

3Move 3 · Question

The question, stated outright.

直接写出研究问题。

4Move 4 · Design

Data, sample and identification in one or two sentences.

用一两句话写数据、样本与识别。

5Move 5 · Contribution

What changes for theory and policy.

对理论与政策有什么改变。

Worked example · Abstract 范例 · 摘要

1Regulators and investors increasingly expect listed firms to disclose environmental, social and governance (ESG) information, and foreign institutional investors are often said to push firms towards better disclosure. 2Yet foreign investors choose which firms to hold, so existing correlations cannot tell us whether they improve disclosure or simply buy firms that already disclose well.

3This project asks whether access by foreign investors causes Chinese listed firms to improve the quality of their ESG disclosure. 4I use the staggered inclusion of A-share firms in the Shanghai- and Shenzhen-Hong Kong Stock Connect programmes as a shock to foreign access, and estimate its effect in a difference-in-differences design on firm-year data from 2010 to 2024. 5The project will provide causal evidence on investor-driven disclosure in the world’s largest emerging market and inform regulators designing market-opening policy.

Why it works 写法解析
1Puzzle 困惑

Starts from a belief that many hold, which the project will test.

从许多人持有的观点出发,项目将检验它。

2Gap 空白

Names the selection problem, the reason correlations are not enough.

点明选择偏差问题,即相关性为何不够。

3Question 问题

One causal question, in one sentence.

一个因果问题,一句话。

4Design 设计

Shock, design, data and period in a single sentence.

冲击、设计、数据与时间段,一句写完。

5Contribution 贡献

Ends on what changes for theory and policy.

以对理论与政策的改变收尾。

Write it last 最后再写

Write the abstract after the rest of the proposal is finished, then check that every sentence matches a section.

摘要最好在整份计划书完成后再写,并核对每句话都能对应到某一部分。

Section 1 第 1 部分
1

Motivation & Research Question研究动机与研究问题

Typical length 典型篇幅 300-500 words · about 13% 约占 13%

Business proposals state the question early, often in the first paragraph, and then explain why it matters for theory and for practice. Lead with a fact or a puzzle a manager, investor or regulator cares about, not with a definition.

商科计划书通常在第一段就提出研究问题,然后说明它对理论与实践的意义。用管理者、投资者或监管者关心的事实或困惑开头,而不是用定义开头。

Blueprint结构

1Para 1 · Fact or puzzle

A current, checkable fact with a citation.

一个当前的、可核查的事实,附引用。

2Para 2 · The question

One causal or explanatory question.

一个因果或解释性问题。

3Para 3 · Why it is hard

The selection or measurement problem.

选择偏差或测量问题。

4Para 4 · Your approach

One line on how you solve it.

一句话说明你如何解决。

Worked example · Motivation (paragraphs 1-4) 范例 · 研究动机(第 1-4 段)

1Over the past decade, regulators in China and elsewhere have moved from encouraging to requiring ESG disclosure by listed firms (Authors, Year), and foreign institutional investors have become an important source of pressure for more transparent reporting (Authors, Year).

2This project asks a simple question: does access by foreign investors cause firms to disclose better ESG information? 3The question is hard to answer because foreign investors are not randomly assigned to firms. They prefer large, liquid and already transparent firms, so a positive correlation between foreign ownership and disclosure quality could reflect their choices rather than their influence.

4I address this problem by exploiting the Stock Connect programmes, which opened eligible Shanghai A-shares to Hong Kong-based investors in 2014 and eligible Shenzhen A-shares in 2016, with later changes to the list of eligible firms. Because eligibility follows index membership rules rather than firms’ disclosure choices, inclusion provides a shock to foreign access that I can use to estimate a causal effect.

Why it works 写法解析
1Fact first 事实开头

Opens with a policy trend and a citation, not a definition of ESG.

以政策趋势和引用开头,而不是解释 ESG 的定义。

2Question early 尽早提问

The research question appears in the second paragraph, in plain words.

研究问题出现在第二段,用词平实。

3Name the problem 点明难点

Shows the panel you understand why the obvious regression is not enough.

让评审看到你明白简单回归为什么不够。

4Preview the fix 预告解决办法

One paragraph previews the identification; Section 3 gives the detail.

用一段预告识别策略,细节放在第 3 部分。

Check every fact about your setting 核实每一个情境事实

Dates, eligibility rules and policy details must come from official exchange or regulator documents, not from news articles or memory. A wrong date in paragraph four puts the whole design in doubt.

日期、入选规则和政策细节必须来自交易所或监管机构的官方文件,而不是新闻或记忆。第四段里错一个日期,整个设计都会受到质疑。

Section 1 continued 第 1 部分(续)

Asking a question a business panel will fund提出评审愿意支持的问题

✕ Weak 较弱“ESG is very important nowadays, and more and more companies care about sustainability.”

Generic; could open any proposal and tells the panel nothing.

空泛,可以放在任何计划书开头,没有给评审任何信息。

✓ Stronger 更好“In 2024, China’s stock exchanges issued sustainability reporting guidelines that require ESG reports from a large group of listed firms (Authors, Year).”

Specific and checkable, with a citation. The reader knows the setting in one line.

具体、可核查且有引用,读者一句话就了解情境。

✕ Weak 较弱“This project studies the relationship between foreign ownership and ESG.”

A relationship is not a question. Which way does it run, and why would it?

“关系”不是问题:方向是什么?为什么会存在?

✓ Stronger 更好“Does access by foreign investors cause firms to improve ESG disclosure quality?”

A causal question with a direction that a design can test.

有方向的因果问题,可以用研究设计检验。

Common motivation mistakes研究动机常见错误

Topic, not question 只有题目没有问题

“I want to study fintech” is an area. Panels need a question.

“我想研究金融科技”只是一个领域,评审需要的是问题。

Practice only 只谈实践

Explaining why firms care, but not what theory gains.

只说企业为什么关心,却没说理论能获得什么。

Hidden question 问题藏得太深

The question appears on page three. Put it in the first 150 words.

问题到第三页才出现。请把它放在前 150 词内。

Management 管理 Open with a managerial dilemma, for example whether remote work helps or hurts innovation, then the question.
Marketing 营销 Open with a consumer behaviour that standard theory does not predict, then the question.
Operations 运营 Open with a cost or service problem in a real system, then the decision you will improve.
Section 2 第 2 部分
2

Literature & Hypotheses文献与假设

Typical length 典型篇幅 600-900 words · about 27% 约占 27%

This is where business proposals differ most from proposals in other fields. A review of studies is not enough here: you use theory to derive hypotheses that your data can reject. Every hypothesis should follow from an argument, and each should have a sign.

这是商科计划书与其他学科差异最大的地方。光综述文献不够,还要用理论推导出能被数据否定的假设。每个假设都应来自一段论证,并有明确的方向。

Blueprint结构

1Strand 1 · The outcome

What drives disclosure quality.

什么驱动披露质量。

2Strand 2 · The cause

What foreign investors do differently.

境外投资者有何不同。

3Theory → H1

The main hypothesis, with a sign.

主假设,有方向。

4Mechanism → H2, H3

Why and where the effect should be stronger.

效应为何及在何处更强。

Worked example · Hypothesis development 范例 · 假设推导

1Disclosure theory predicts that firms disclose more when the benefits, such as a lower cost of capital, outweigh the costs of revealing information (Authors, Year). ESG disclosure is largely voluntary in quality even where it is required in form, so firms keep wide discretion over how much useful information they provide (Authors, Year).

2Foreign institutional investors tend to hold longer horizons, face stronger ESG mandates from their own clients, and rely more on public information because they are far from the firm (Authors, Year). They therefore raise the benefit of disclosure to the firm. 3H1: Firms included in Stock Connect improve the quality of their ESG disclosure relative to comparable firms not yet included.

4If the effect works through investors’ demand for information, it should be larger where information is otherwise scarce. H2: The effect of inclusion is stronger for firms with lower analyst coverage. If it works through monitoring, it should be larger where foreign holdings actually rise. H3: The effect is stronger for firms with larger increases in northbound holdings after inclusion.

Why it works 写法解析
1Theory first 理论先行

Starts from a named theory, not from a list of papers.

从一个具体理论出发,而不是罗列论文。

2Why this investor 为何是这类投资者

Explains what is different about foreign investors, which is the bridge to H1.

说明境外投资者的不同之处,这是通向 H1 的桥梁。

3Signed hypothesis 有方向的假设

H1 says which way the effect goes and compared with whom.

H1 写明效应方向,以及与谁比较。

4Mechanism tests 机制检验

H2 and H3 separate two explanations, and panels look for this.

H2 与 H3 区分两种解释,评审看重这一点。

Section 2 continued 第 2 部分(续)

Writing hypotheses that can fail写出可以被否定的假设

✕ Weak 较弱“H1: Foreign investors affect ESG.”

No direction, no comparison, no measurable outcome. Any result would “support” it.

没有方向、比较对象和可测量的结果,任何结果都能“支持”它。

✓ Stronger 更好“H1: Firms included in Stock Connect improve ESG disclosure quality relative to comparable firms not yet included.”

Direction, outcome and comparison group are all clear, so the data can reject it.

方向、结果与对照组都很清楚,数据可以否定它。

✕ Weak 较弱A literature review that summarises fifteen papers, one per paragraph.

A list, not an argument. The reader cannot see where the hypotheses come from.

这是清单而不是论证,读者看不出假设从何而来。

✓ Stronger 更好Three strands, each ending in the step it adds to your argument.

Synthesis that leads straight to the hypotheses.

综合各脉络,直接引出假设。

A good hypothesis checklist好假设的检查清单

CHECK 检查项WHAT IT MEANS 含义
Derived 有推导It follows from the argument in the paragraph before it. 它来自前一段的论证。
Signed 有方向It says increase or decrease, stronger or weaker. 写明增加或减少、更强或更弱。
Comparable 有比较It names what the treated firms are compared with. 写明处理组与谁比较。
Measurable 可测量Every term matches a variable in Section 3. 每个术语都对应第 3 部分的一个变量。
Distinct 可区分Mechanism hypotheses predict different patterns, so the data can tell them apart. 机制假设预测不同的模式,数据能把它们区分开。
Management 管理 Derive hypotheses from a named theory, such as the resource-based view or social exchange theory, and state moderators.
Marketing 营销 State a main effect, then a mediator (the process) and a moderator (when it reverses).
Operations 运营 State propositions from the model, such as “optimal price falls as demand uncertainty rises”.
Section 3 第 3 部分
3

Data & Identification数据与识别策略

Typical length 典型篇幅 800-1,100 words · about 33% 约占 33%

Business panels decide here whether you can do the work. Name the data sources and sample, define every variable, state the regression or model, and explain why your design separates cause from correlation. Then show what you will do if the main assumption is challenged.

商科评审在这一部分判断你能否完成研究。写明数据来源与样本,定义每个变量,写出回归或模型,并解释为什么你的设计能区分因果与相关。然后说明如果核心假设受到质疑,你会怎么做。

Blueprint结构

1 · Data & sample

Sources, period, filters, sample size.

来源、时间段、筛选、样本量。

2 · Variables

Outcome, treatment, controls, each defined.

结果、处理与控制变量,逐一定义。

3 · Model

The equation and what each term does.

方程式及每一项的作用。

4 · Threats & tests

Parallel trends, placebo, alternative measures.

平行趋势、安慰剂检验、替代指标。

Worked example · Data and identification 范例 · 数据与识别

1Data and sample. The sample covers all non-financial A-share firms from 2010 to 2024. Financial data and ownership come from CSMAR; ESG ratings and report characteristics from a commercial ESG database; Stock Connect eligibility lists and dates from the exchanges’ official announcements. After standard filters I expect around 3,000 firms and 30,000 firm-years.

2Variables. The outcome is ESG disclosure quality, measured by a disclosure score and, as an alternative, by the length and quantitative content of ESG reports. The treatment equals one from the year a firm becomes eligible for Stock Connect. Controls include size, leverage, profitability, growth, board independence and state ownership.

3Model. I estimate a staggered difference-in-differences model with firm and year fixed effects: Disclosureit = β·Connectit + γ·Controlsit + αi + δt + εit, with standard errors clustered by firm. Because effects may differ across inclusion waves, I will also use an estimator designed for staggered adoption (Authors, Year).

4Threats. An event-study plot will test for pre-trends. A placebo test assigns false inclusion dates. Firms just above and below the index cut-off provide a tighter comparison, and results will be repeated with an alternative disclosure measure.

Why it works 写法解析
1Named sources 具体来源

Each variable has a named source, so feasibility is visible.

每个变量都有具体来源,可行性一目了然。

2Defined variables 变量有定义

Outcome, treatment and controls are each defined, with one alternative measure.

结果、处理与控制变量都有定义,并给出一个替代指标。

3The equation 写出方程

Writing the model shows the panel you can run it.

写出模型能让评审看到你会操作。

4Threats answered 回应质疑

Pre-trends, placebo and a tighter comparison answer the questions a panel will ask.

预趋势、安慰剂与更严格的对照回应评审会提的问题。

Section 3 continued 第 3 部分(续)

Making the design convincing让研究设计更有说服力

✕ Weak 较弱“I will collect data and use regression analysis to study the relationship.”

No data source, no model, no identification. The panel cannot judge whether it is causal or feasible.

没有数据来源、模型和识别策略,评审无法判断因果性和可行性。

✓ Stronger 更好“Staggered difference-in-differences on CSMAR firm-years, 2010-2024, with firm and year fixed effects and an event-study test of pre-trends.”

A supervisor could start planning the analysis from this one line.

导师凭这一句就能开始规划分析。

✕ Weak 较弱“The results will show that foreign investors improve ESG.”

Predicts the result and ignores the risk that it does not hold.

预设了结果,也忽略了结果不成立的风险。

✓ Stronger 更好“If the main effect is not found, the mechanism tests still show whether foreign holdings changed analyst attention or disclosure length.”

Shows the project produces a contribution whatever the result.

表明无论结果如何,项目都能产出贡献。

Feasibility checklist可行性清单

CHECK 检查项WHAT THE PANEL WANTS TO SEE 评审希望看到
Data access 数据获取Databases the school subscribes to, or a source you already have. Check the library list before you name a database. 学校订阅的数据库或你已掌握的数据。写数据库名称前先核对学校图书馆清单。
Skills 技能Econometrics and software you already use (Stata, R, Python), and the PhD courses that will fill the gaps. 你已掌握的计量方法与软件(Stata、R、Python),以及博士课程如何补足不足。
Test score 考试成绩A strong quantitative GMAT or GRE score supports your claim that you can run the method. GMAT 或 GRE 数学部分考得好,能说明你用得了这种方法。
Risks 风险One or two risks with a fallback, such as a short pre-period or a weak first stage. 一两个风险及备选,如事前期过短或第一阶段较弱。
Management 管理 Name the organisations or survey panel, the constructs and validated scales, and the model, such as multilevel SEM.
Marketing 营销 Describe Study 1 in full (design, conditions, sample, measure) and one line for each later study; pre-register.
Operations 运营 State the model, the data or simulation that calibrates it, and the benchmark policy you will beat.
Section 4 第 4 部分
4

Contribution & Fit贡献与匹配度

Typical length 典型篇幅 250-400 words · about 12% 约占 12%

Say exactly which conversation in the literature you join and what you add to it, then why these faculty and this school. Business faculty read the fit section to judge whether they could co-author with you.

准确说明你加入哪一场学术讨论、贡献是什么,再说明为什么是这些老师和这所学校。商学院老师读匹配部分,是想判断能不能和你合写论文。

Blueprint结构

1Contribution to literature

Name the stream and what you add.

点明文献脉络与你的增量。

2Contribution to practice

Who uses the result, and how.

谁会使用这个结论、如何使用。

3Faculty fit

Two named faculty and a specific link each.

两位老师,各有具体联系。

4Readiness

Your data, skills and prior work.

你的数据、技能与前期工作。

Worked example · Contribution and fit 范例 · 贡献与匹配度

1The project contributes to research on institutional investors and corporate disclosure by providing causal evidence from a large emerging market, where most existing evidence is correlational (Authors, Year). 2For regulators, it shows whether opening markets to foreign investors is an effective complement to mandatory ESG rules.

3I am applying to the School of Accounting and Finance because Professor A’s work on foreign ownership and information environments (Authors, Year) addresses the mechanism in H2, and Dr B’s research on difference-in-differences methods in accounting (Authors, Year) matches my identification strategy. The school’s access to CSMAR and to commercial ESG databases makes the project feasible from the first year.

4My MSc dissertation used ESG ratings and panel regressions in Stata, and as a research assistant I cleaned and merged CSMAR ownership data, so I can begin building the dataset immediately.

Why it works 写法解析
1Join a conversation 加入学术对话

Names the stream and the specific gap, correlation without causation.

点明文献脉络与具体空白:只有相关、缺乏因果。

2Practice 实践意义

One sentence on who uses the result.

一句话说明谁会使用这一结论。

3Faculty fit 导师匹配

Links one faculty member to the mechanism and another to the method.

一位老师对应机制,另一位对应方法。

4Readiness 准备度

Prior data work proves you can start now.

前期数据工作证明你可以马上开始。

✕ Weak 较弱“I chose this school because it is ranked in the top 50 for finance.”

Says nothing about research or people.

没有提到研究,也没有提到老师。

✓ Stronger 更好“Dr B’s work on difference-in-differences in accounting (Authors, Year) matches my identification strategy.”

Names a person, a paper and the exact link to the project.

点名一位老师、一篇论文,以及与项目的确切联系。

Section 5 第 5 部分
5

Timeline, Coursework & Feasibility时间安排、课程与可行性

Typical length 典型篇幅 150-250 words or one table · about 8% 约占 8%

Many business PhDs begin with doctoral coursework and a first-year review, and the thesis is usually a set of papers. In Hong Kong, university studentships run for up to four years at HKUST and CityU, with a qualifying examination or candidacy stage before the thesis, as at CityU and CUHK. Show that you know how your programme runs and plan the thesis as papers.

许多商科博士以博士课程和第一年评审开始,论文通常由一组文章组成。在香港,港科大与城大的大学研究生奖学金最长资助四年,论文阶段之前设有资格考试或候选资格阶段,例如城大和港中文。要表明你了解所申项目的结构,并把论文规划为一组文章。

Worked example · Timeline (four-year programme) 范例 · 时间安排(四年制项目)

PERIOD 时间ACTIVITY 活动OUTPUT 产出
Year 1Doctoral coursework in econometrics, finance and accounting theory; build the firm-year datasetCoursework passed; dataset v1
Year 1 endQualifying examination or first-year review (check your school)Pass; second-year paper plan
Year 2Paper 1: main effect (H1) with event study and robustnessWorking paper; conference submission
Year 3Paper 2: mechanisms (H2, H3); thesis proposal defenceSecond working paper
Year 4Paper 3: real effects such as cost of capital; job-market paper; thesis submissionThesis; job-market paper

2Risk: if the ESG database does not cover early years, the main tests start in 2014 and the pre-period uses report-text measures built from annual reports.

Why it works 写法解析
1Coursework first 课程先行

Shows you understand the structure of a business PhD.

表明你了解商科博士的结构。

2Papers, not chapters 以论文为单位

Business theses are usually three papers; the plan says so.

商科论文通常由三篇文章组成,计划中写明这一点。

Research-only routes 纯研究型路径

Where the PhD is three years of research with no coursework, plan month by month, move Paper 1 into Year 1 and put the first-year review at month 9 to 12.

如果博士是三年纯研究、没有课程,请按月规划,把第一篇论文移到第一年,并把第一年评审安排在第 9 至 12 个月。

Section 6 第 6 部分
6

References参考文献

Usually excluded from the word count 通常不计字数 20-35 core sources

Cite the leading journals of your field and the papers that define your identification strategy. A reference list drawn mainly from top journals tells a business panel you know where the conversation happens.

引用本领域顶级期刊和界定你识别策略的论文。以顶级期刊为主的参考文献,能让商科评审看到你知道学术对话在哪里发生。

Blueprint结构

Field journals

For example the leading journals in accounting, finance, management or marketing.

例如会计、金融、管理或营销领域的顶级期刊。

Method papers

The papers behind your estimator or design.

你所用估计方法或设计的出处论文。

The supervisor

Their work, where it applies to your project.

在确实相关时引用导师的研究。

One style

APA 7 or the school’s house style, used consistently.

APA 7 或学校规定格式,前后统一。

Worked example · Reference list (excerpt) 范例 · 参考文献节选

Author, A. A., & Author, B. B. (Year). Foreign institutional investors and corporate disclosure. Journal Name, 00(0), 000-000.

Author, C. C. (Year). Difference-in-differences with variation in treatment timing. Journal Name, 00(0), 000-000.

Author, D. D., & Author, E. E. (Year). Market liberalisation and firm behaviour: evidence from Stock Connect. Journal Name, 00(0), 000-000.

Why it works 写法解析
1Real sources only 只用真实文献

In your own proposal every reference must be a paper you have read.

你自己的计划书里,每条参考文献都必须是你读过的论文。

2Include the method 引用方法来源

Citing the estimator shows you know its assumptions.

引用估计方法的出处,表明你了解其前提假设。

Textbooks and websites 教材与网页

Citing textbooks or news sites instead of research papers.

引用教材或新闻网站而不是研究论文。

Old literature only 只有旧文献

Missing the last five years, where most methods have changed.

缺少近五年的文献,而方法多在这期间更新。

Broken citations 引用不匹配

In-text citations missing from the list.

正文引用在参考文献中找不到。

Putting it to work 实际应用

Adapting to each university按校调整

Keep the 3,000-word master version and cut from it, in this order. Never write a new proposal for each school; change the fit section and trim.

保留 3,000 词母版,按下列顺序裁剪。不要为每所学校重写,只需调整匹配部分并删减。

TARGET 目标WHAT TO DO 做法
Developed proposal (3,000 words or more)
完整研究计划(3,000 词以上)
HKU Business School: a proposal of 6-8 pages 港大商学院 6-8 页
Use the master version; add the expected-results table or pilot evidence if you have it.
使用母版;如有预期结果表或预试证据可补充。
Indicative proposal (about 1,000-2,000 words)
初步研究计划(约 1,000-2,000 词)
CUHK (personal statement plus a research proposal or plan); HKUST (proposal plus a vision statement of up to 2,000 characters); PolyU (Form GSB/1A); CityU Management (research plan) 港中文、港科大、理大、城大管理学
Keep Sections 1-3 in short form: one paragraph of motivation, three hypotheses, a one-paragraph design with the model in words. Timeline in two lines.
第 1-3 部分精简:一段研究动机、三个假设、一段文字描述的设计。时间安排两行。
Faculty contact or agreement first
先联系老师或取得同意
CityU (seek a supervisor’s consent before you apply) 城大
Send a one-page summary with H1, the data and the two faculty you want; write the full proposal after they respond.
先发送包含 H1、数据与两位意向老师的一页摘要,收到回复后再写完整计划书。

The email before the proposal计划书之前的那封邮件

In Hong Kong your first email is part of the application. CityU asks for a supervisor’s consent before you apply, and because universities pre-screen and nominate HKPFS candidates, a supervisor who already knows your plan helps everywhere. Write in September or October, well before 1 December. Give the supervisor enough detail to judge the fit: one specific link to their work, your question and method in one sentence each, one easy question, and your CV plus a short summary attached. Write the first draft yourself; your academic will check the tailored paragraph.

在香港,第一封邮件就是申请的一部分。城大要求申请前先取得导师同意;由于各校会先筛选并提名 HKPFS 候选人,一位已经了解你计划的导师在任何学校都有帮助。请在 9 月或 10 月发出,远早于 12 月 1 日。写得足够详细,让导师能判断是否匹配:联系对方一项具体研究,用一句话写研究问题、一句话写方法,只问一个容易回答的问题,并附简历和一份简短摘要。第一稿由你自己撰写,导师只负责核对针对导师的那一段。

Before you submit 提交之前

Read it like a panel用评审的眼光重读

Reread your proposal as a faculty member with ten minutes and forty others to read. Score each question 1 (weak), 2 (adequate) or 3 (strong), and fix the lowest score first.

像一位只有十分钟、还有四十份要读的老师那样重读。每项打 1(弱)、2(一般)、3(强)分,先修改得分最低的一项。

#CHECK 检查SELF-SCORE 自评
1Can I state the question in one sentence from memory? 我能凭记忆用一句话说出研究问题吗?1 2 3
2Does every hypothesis follow from an argument and have a sign? 每个假设都来自论证并有方向吗?1 2 3
3Have I named the data source for every variable? 每个变量都写明了数据来源吗?1 2 3
4Does my design explain why the effect is causal, and how I test that? 我的设计说明了效应为何是因果、如何检验吗?1 2 3
5Is the fit section specific to named faculty at this school? 匹配部分是否针对这所学校的具体老师?1 2 3
6Does the timeline include coursework and a fallback? 时间安排包含课程和备选方案吗?1 2 3
7Is it the right document type and length for this school? 文件类型和篇幅符合这所学校的要求吗?1 2 3

Three tests三个测试

The referee test

Imagine a journal referee reads Section 3. What is their first objection? Answer it in the text.

想象期刊审稿人读第 3 部分,第一个质疑是什么?在正文中回答它。

The faculty test

Would the named faculty recognise their own work in your fit section? If not, rewrite it.

被点名的老师能在你的匹配部分认出自己的研究吗?不能就重写。

The two-minute test

Explain the question, the shock and the result you expect in two minutes. Where you stumble, the writing is unclear.

用两分钟讲清问题、冲击与预期结果。卡壳的地方就是写得不清楚的地方。